Since starting the Trim Healthy Mama plan I’ve been craving something ooey, gooey and rich. But most of the recipes I come across are filled to the brim with on-plan chocolate. Which, I’m sure is delicious and good and rich. But, as I’ve told you before I’m allergic to chocolate. So caramel and peanut butter have been my go-to substitutes since my allergy discovery. So I have been craving something peanut buttery.  This post contains affiliate 3rd party links where products may be purchased resulting in possible paid compensation for this blogger. Having lived in Ohio near to Amish country for so long, I’m no stranger to Goo-oood peanut butter pie.…